The Jedi Academy. THE Place for Jedi training.
Forums
Content
The Academy
Learn
Communicate
Personal


Forums | Star Wars Discussion
Who Are The True Heroes In Star Wars?!
Aug 04 2010 12:33am

Silya Beedoess
 - Student
Silya Beedoess
Alot of people think of General Grievous, Asajj Ventress,and Dooku (or Dorku as I like to call him) as the villians and the jedi always being the "heroes". Think again.:P Don't get me wronge, I think the jedi are as great as the next guy, but there is alot that's left unsaid in the movies and the "Star Wars: The Clone Wars" series. If you have any questions or comments about this please post them up. I'd be more than happy to here from you all.:alliance::)
_______________
I read up alot on the Star Wars characters,so if you want to know more about one of them I'm the fan to talk to.
Kit Fisto and General Grievous are also my favorite characters of them all.
May the force forever be with you.
-Silya Beeodess

Poll
In your eyes, who is a TRUE hero?

vote results

< Recent Comments Login and add your comment!  
Comments
Aug 16 2010 09:19pm

Cloud Senatu
 - Student
 Cloud Senatu

Yeah, well who knows what they were thinking, or how they just let him on by. I never really understood it, only tried to understand it.

Aug 16 2010 04:03am

Silya Beedoess
 - Student
 Silya Beedoess

They didn't have to sense he was a sith though only if someone other then a jedi was there. Plus Cato already gave away the fact that Bane was the one who stole the holocron.
_______________
I read up alot on the Star Wars characters,so if you want to know more about one of them I'm the fan to talk to.
Kit Fisto and General Grievous are also my favorite characters of them all.
May the force forever be with you.
-Silya Beeodess


Aug 15 2010 09:09pm

Cloud Senatu
 - Student
 Cloud Senatu

Yes, they should have stayed on their guard, doesn't mean they were purposely sensing everyone with the Force to see if they were a Sith. That's probably why he was able to get passed them all without much of an issue. Because he was able to slip past them while they were looking, not sensing, for the intruder.

This comment was edited by Cloud Senatu on Aug 15 2010 09:10pm.

Aug 15 2010 06:02pm

Silya Beedoess
 - Student
 Silya Beedoess

Oh, but didn't they alert everyone in the temple that there was an intruder? They wouldn't have been able to tell everyone that fast that they had caught Cato Parasitti. Plus they knew someone had stolen a holocron other than Cato so everyone should have stayed on their guard for a while.
_______________
I read up alot on the Star Wars characters,so if you want to know more about one of them I'm the fan to talk to.
Kit Fisto and General Grievous are also my favorite characters of them all.
May the force forever be with you.
-Silya Beeodess


Aug 15 2010 06:33am

Cloud Senatu
 - Student
 Cloud Senatu

Well yes, but if a Jedi isn't purposely trying to sense them, and the Dark Side is clouding their minds even slightly...they won't realize it. Palpatine or someone else, doesn't quite matter then. The fact still remains the same.

Aug 15 2010 05:14am

Silya Beedoess
 - Student
 Silya Beedoess

Yea, but Cad Bane is different from Palpatine. At least one Jedi should have sensed him. I mean think about it. He had to not only pass all the Jedi in the library, but also throughout the Jedi Temple to get out of there.
_______________
I read up alot on the Star Wars characters,so if you want to know more about one of them I'm the fan to talk to.
Kit Fisto and General Grievous are also my favorite characters of them all.
May the force forever be with you.
-Silya Beeodess


This comment was edited by Silya Beedoess on Aug 15 2010 05:14am.

Aug 15 2010 03:37am

Cloud Senatu
 - Student
 Cloud Senatu

Yeah, that is rather true. I think what it is, is the Dark Side sometimes clouds their minds into the way so that they can't sense them. I mean, they did say the Dark Side surrounded Palpatine.

Aug 14 2010 04:36am

Silya Beedoess
 - Student
 Silya Beedoess

Well they sure assumed the Trade Fedration and IGBC. Plus don't forget in "Holocron Hiest", Cad Bane walked past all the Jedi and none of them noticed.
_______________
I read up alot on the Star Wars characters,so if you want to know more about one of them I'm the fan to talk to.
Kit Fisto and General Grievous are also my favorite characters of them all.
May the force forever be with you.
-Silya Beeodess


This comment was edited by Silya Beedoess on Aug 14 2010 05:56am.

Aug 14 2010 01:54am

Cloud Senatu
 - Student
 Cloud Senatu

Yeah, but they never saw Sidious, so they couldn't have known. The Dark Side also was around Palpatine a lot, so they couldn't fully sense it.. They did have a strong idea, though, but they couldn't assume.

Aug 13 2010 12:19am

Silya Beedoess
 - Student
 Silya Beedoess

I'm suprised Yoda didn't find out, at least not after so long I think. Then again... I'm talking about the guy who sat a two feet away from Darth Sidious and didn't know anything. How hard is it to figure out!!!!???? It's like "Cloak on; cloak off; cloak on; cloak off." "Palpatine; Darth Sidious; Palpatine; Darth Sidious."
_______________
I read up alot on the Star Wars characters,so if you want to know more about one of them I'm the fan to talk to.
Kit Fisto and General Grievous are also my favorite characters of them all.
May the force forever be with you.
-Silya Beeodess


This comment was edited by Silya Beedoess on Aug 13 2010 12:20am.

Aug 12 2010 06:07am

Cloud Senatu
 - Student
 Cloud Senatu

Yeah, like I said it's not unheard of. But it was still not something that was allowed by the Order. Yes, Obi-Wan did 100% know when he asked Padme, but I personally feel he knew about them not long after they were married...I mean, it's Obi-Wan! But yeah.

Aug 12 2010 01:18am

Silya Beedoess
 - Student
 Silya Beedoess

He did end up finding out anyway because he asked Padme if Anakin was the father, and I once read in a book that a jedi in that era and when Anakin was a kid, maybe around 12, had married.
_______________
I read up alot on the Star Wars characters,so if you want to know more about one of them I'm the fan to talk to.
Kit Fisto and General Grievous are also my favorite characters of them all.
May the force forever be with you.
-Silya Beeodess


Aug 11 2010 02:18am

Cloud Senatu
 - Student
 Cloud Senatu

That actually isn't true, it wasn't something he thought, it was a fact that Obi-Wan actually told him in Episode 2 if you remember. It was actually strictly against the order during that era. So yeah, Anakin knew, even if he talked it over with Obi-Wan. Obi-Wan might have helped him, and spoke with him, might even have kept it a secret, which I believe he did...because I think Obi-Wan did know.

Aug 11 2010 12:03am

Silya Beedoess
 - Student
 Silya Beedoess

He didn't know that. He THOUGHT that. If he talked to his master about it maybe things could have gone differently.
_______________
I read up alot on the Star Wars characters,so if you want to know more about one of them I'm the fan to talk to.
Kit Fisto and General Grievous are also my favorite characters of them all.
May the force forever be with you.
-Silya Beeodess


Aug 10 2010 07:29am

Cloud Senatu
 - Student
 Cloud Senatu

Yeah, if they didn't keep it a secret, I bet a lot of shit wouldn't have happened...but also, Anakin would have been removed from the Order, and that COULD have prevented a lot of things too.

Aug 10 2010 02:07am

Silya Beedoess
 - Student
 Silya Beedoess

I know!! They would be perfect for each other. The thing with Anakin and Padme is though that they keep it a secret.
_______________
I read up alot on the Star Wars characters,so if you want to know more about one of them I'm the fan to talk to.
Kit Fisto and General Grievous are also my favorite characters of them all.
May the force forever be with you.
-Silya Beeodess


Aug 09 2010 06:24pm

Cloud Senatu
 - Student
 Cloud Senatu

Well Anakin and Padme have already done that. There is also another example, but I can't remember their names. I would have loved to see Kit Fisto and Aayla Secura get together...those two just deserve each other!

Aug 08 2010 08:08pm

Silya Beedoess
 - Student
 Silya Beedoess

:( I feel bad for all the jedi that aren't allowed to marry. If they took away that rule, there would be who knows how many jedi immediatly going to the ones the loved. Satine and Obi-wan, Aayla Secura and Kit Fisto, and Anakin and Padme are only a few examples.
_______________
I read up alot on the Star Wars characters,so if you want to know more about one of them I'm the fan to talk to.
Kit Fisto and General Grievous are also my favorite characters of them all.
May the force forever be with you.
-Silya Beeodess


This comment was edited by Silya Beedoess on Aug 08 2010 08:08pm.

Aug 08 2010 02:13am

Cloud Senatu
 - Student
 Cloud Senatu

Yeah, Obi-Wan could control his emotions. But back then, relationships were forbidden. They weren't allowed until after Luke Skywalker defeated the Emperor and created the New Jedi Order. That's when it was more acceptable for there to be attachments like that.

Aug 08 2010 12:18am

Silya Beedoess
 - Student
 Silya Beedoess

True, but a jedi such as Obi-Wan would be able to control his emotions. Along with Satine, he actually used to love a jedi named Fay and when she died he seemed to control everything pretty well.
_______________
I read up alot on the Star Wars characters,so if you want to know more about one of them I'm the fan to talk to.
Kit Fisto and General Grievous are also my favorite characters of them all.
May the force forever be with you.
-Silya Beeodess


Aug 06 2010 06:37am

Cloud Senatu
 - Student
 Cloud Senatu

Well, it depends on what era you're thinking about. When Luke Skywalker became the Grand Master of the Jedi Order, he actually made it fine for one to marry...and if you really look deep enough, the Jedi want you to love each other as Family almost, so actually it isn't all that bad if you married another Jedi....sometimes. It's a difficult path, either way. Because you have to understand the emotions that will come with it...

Aug 05 2010 11:28pm

Silya Beedoess
 - Student
 Silya Beedoess

You know, I've read that some Jedi other then Anakin have married. I wonder why they could when many others can't.
_______________
I read up alot on the Star Wars characters,so if you want to know more about one of them I'm the fan to talk to.
Kit Fisto and General Grievous are also my favorite characters of them all.
May the force forever be with you.
-Silya Beeodess


Aug 05 2010 06:00am

Cloud Senatu
 - Student
 Cloud Senatu

Quote:
I think Obi-Wan is cool too. I feel really bad though that he can't really follow his heart when it comes to Satine and all.:(


Waaay to true there.

Aug 04 2010 11:32pm

Silya Beedoess
 - Student
 Silya Beedoess

I think Obi-Wan is cool too. I feel really bad though that he can't really follow his heart when it comes to Satine and all.:(
_______________
I read up alot on the Star Wars characters,so if you want to know more about one of them I'm the fan to talk to.
Kit Fisto and General Grievous are also my favorite characters of them all.
May the force forever be with you.
-Silya Beeodess


This comment was edited by Silya Beedoess on Aug 04 2010 11:33pm.

Aug 04 2010 03:00am

Cloud Senatu
 - Student
 Cloud Senatu

I personally would have to say Obi-Wan. I mean, look at what all he has done. True, in the process of training Anakin, he trained a guy that became a Sith...but Anakin then, after a long time, turned around and destroyed the Sith.
So in the end, you could say that would have never happened if it wasn't for Obi-Wan. Because no one else would have trained Anakin since Qui-Gon died.

< Recent Comments Login and add your comment!